1st Edition
Moral Agency in Eastern and Western Thought Perspectives on Crafting Character
This volume explores how individuals use moral agency to craft the moral dispositions and moral capabilities needed for living well-lived lives. It draws on Eastern and Western philosophical and ethical traditions to formulate and address key issues concerning character development and moral agency.
In both Eastern and Western traditions, the complexities of shaping an individual’s moral agency focus on sustained processes of inner self-cultivation. The chapters in this volume highlight the ways in which one is to manage and direct one’s desires and aspirations, and what is to count as the source of guidance for a well-lived life. They engage with key figures and traditions in the history of Eastern and Western philosophy, including Confucian, Buddhist, and Western sources, from Aristotle to Kant. The juxtaposition of sources from the different parts of the world highlights striking similarities and significant contrasts and provides rich conceptual resources for further exploration of these issues. The volume provides a broader, deeper pursuit of central issues of moral psychology and ethics in ways that highlight the inexhaustible resources in these traditions. The focus on character is a way to draw together perspectives on ethical life, theories of human agency, views of fundamental, life-guiding values, and relations between individuals and society and how persons see their place in the world.
Moral Agency in Eastern and Western Thought will appeal to scholars and advanced students working on virtue ethics, moral psychology, comparative philosophy, and history of philosophy.
Part 1: Introduction
1. Exploring Moral Agency Across Traditions Jonathan Jacobs and Heinz-Dieter Meyer
Part 2: Perspectives on Agency and Character
2. Early Confucianism as a Model for Crafting Character Philip J. Ivanhoe
3. Moral Habituation and Technē in Aristotle’s Ethics Tom Angier
4. Crafting Character: Lessons from Confucianism and Stoicism May Sim
5. The Zen Transformation of Ordinary Life into Buddhist Practice: Eating and Drinking as Exploration of Buddha-Nature Christopher W. Gowans
6. Must We Become Who We Are? Aristotle, Confucius, and Maimonides on Moral Agency and Character Jonathan Jacobs
7. The Heart-Mind as that Which Needs Moral Formation: Heinz-Dieter Meyer
8. Kant on Self-Governance: The Structural Nexus of Practical Reason, Will, and Gemüt (Mind) G. Felicitas Munzel
9. On the Use and Misuse of Moral Exemplars for Self-Improvement Amber D. Carpenter
10. Crafting Character with Aristotle and Augustine George Heffernan
11. Moral Agency, Situationism, and Virtue: Xunzi on Moral Development Richard Kim
12. Selfless Agency and the Cultivation of a Moral Character: Insights from Vasubandhu and Derek Parfit Oren Hanner
13. The Formation of Moral Character Through No-Self in Neo-Confucian Thought Doil Kim
Part 3: Character and Commensurability
14. The Heart-Mind in the West—Testing for Common Ground Heinz-Dieter Meyer
15. A Look Back to Find a Way Forward Jonathan Jacobs
Biography
Jonathan Jacobs (PhD, University of Pennsylvania) is Professor of Philosophy and Director of the Institute for Criminal Justice Ethics at John Jay College/CUNY. He is also a member of the Doctoral Faculty of Philosophy at CUNY. His most recent books are The Liberal State and Criminal Sanction: Seeking Justice and Civility, (Oxford University Press 2020) and Criminology and Moral Philosophy: Empirical Methods and the Study of Values (Routledge 2022). Jacobs has held Fulbright Scholar, NEH, and Earhart Foundation grants, and has been a Visiting Professor or Visiting Fellow at University of Edinburgh, Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hebrew University, University of St. Andrews, Oxford Centre for Hebrew & Jewish Studies, and is a Life Member of Clare Hall, Cambridge. He is also the editor of the journal Criminal Justice Ethics.
Heinz-Dieter Meyer (PhD, Cornell University) is Professor of education at State University of New York (Albany). He has been Harman Fellow at Harvard University and received a National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH) award. He has taught at Goettingen University and been Visiting Professor at Penn State University, Beijing University, Boston University, and the East-West Institute (Honolulu). His recent publications include Knowledge and Civil Society (with Glueckler and Suarsana), 2021, and The Design of the University: German, American, and 'World Class' (Routledge 2017).
