1st Edition

The U.S. Constitution’s Eighth Amendment Bail, Fines, and Punishments

By Charlie Eastaugh Copyright 2025
    328 Pages
    by Routledge

    328 Pages
    by Routledge

    The U.S. Constitution’s Eighth Amendment: Bail, Fines, and Punishments is an in-depth exploration of the Eighth Amendment's pivotal role in American jurisprudence. This comprehensive case-book is the very first of its kind, dedicated entirely to the Eighth Amendment, with every relevant Supreme Court precedent included to 2025.

    The book delves into the intricacies of bail, fines, and punishments litigation, featuring key excerpts from landmark Supreme Court cases which have defined the Amendment over the past 200 years. This work examines the historical context and evolving interpretations of the Amendment, starting with its origin in English Law and highlighting the impact of Supreme Court jurisprudence on the wider justice system. Through detailed analysis of major cases and carefully edited opinions, the book reveals how the Eighth Amendment shapes debates on relevant issues, providing unique insights into cases and addressing contemporary issues like mental health, confinement conditions, the vanishing applicability of the death penalty, and the importance of individualization in sentencing and punishment.

    Ideal for legal scholars, practitioners, and anyone interested in constitutional law, this is a vital resource for understanding one of the Constitution's most essential protections.

    Introduction

    Chapter 1. Framing and early history

    The Eighth Amendment’s English and common law roots

    Punishments context

    The Eighth Amendment in the early United States

    The Eighth lands on the Supreme Court’s docket

    Chapter 2. Interpretation and incorporation

    Constitutional history and the backdrop of incorporation

    The era of incorporation

    Interpreting the Eighth Amendment

    The beginning of a departure from evolutive decision-making?

    Chapter 3. Excessive Bail

    Incorporation of the Bail Clause

    Bail before the Court

    Chapter 4. Fines

    History of the Fines Clause

    1980s and 1990s review

    Due process claims

    Incorporating the Fines Clause

    Chapter 5. The death penalty, from Furman to Gregg and beyond

    Furman reaches the Court

    The machinery of death, rebooted

    Gregg’s legacy

    Chapter 6. Limits on capital categories: classes of offence

    Non-homicidal rape

    Felony murder

    Non-homicidal child rape

    Chapter 7. Limits on capital offenders

    Youth in capital sentencing

    Intellectually disabled offenders

    Chapter 8. Execution protocols

    Early death penalty methods

    The lethal injection

    21st Century innovation

    Chapter 9. Equal application and racial bias

    Chapter 10. Non-capital proscriptions

    Life imprisonment and proportionality

    Revisiting proportionality

    Juveniles and non-capital proportionality

    Chapter 11. Confinement conditions and inmate rights

    Extending punishments adjudication to prison health and safety

    Confinement conditions at the turn of the century: caveating the limitations

    Mass incarceration on trial

    Unconstitutional solitude?

    Conclusion

    Biography

    Charlie Eastaugh holds a First Class Honours degree (LLB) in English Law and a Ph.D. in U.S. Constitutional Law. His first book, Unconstitutional Solitude, focusing on the legality of long-term solitary.